Biden-era spending law found unconstitutional by federal appeals court

CNN
Original Story by CNN
November 21, 2026
Biden-era spending law found unconstitutional by federal appeals court

An appeals court ruled that a Biden-related funding measure was unconstitutional, highlighting a judicial check on how Congress funds federal actions. The ruling centers on whether funds were legally appropriated, with the House arguing there was no valid appropriation and the defense invoking a permanent appropriation statute. The court found that the House had standing because the Executive Branch drew Treasury funds without congressional authorization, underscoring the constitutional primacy of appropriations. The decision reinforces the separation of powers in fiscal matters and suggests ongoing scrutiny of how funding is sourced and administered. Looking ahead, the ruling could shape how future spending bills are framed and challenged.

Dive Deeper:

  • The decision concerns a funding bill tied to President Biden and the constitutional adequacy of its appropriations, focusing on whether the payments had a valid legislative basis.

  • The House contends there was no proper appropriation for the payments, challenging the legality of disbursements from the Treasury.

  • Defendants argued that 31 U.S.C. § 1324 provides a permanent appropriation, which would make the payments lawful without new congressional action.

  • The court held that the House had standing to sue because executive branch actions drew funds without congressional authorization, violating the Appropriations Clause of the Constitution.

  • The ruling emphasizes the constitutional requirement for explicit appropriations and the authority of Congress over federal spending decisions.

  • Implications point to a heightened emphasis on legislative control over funding mechanisms and potential limits on executive-led disbursements without explicit appropriations.

Latest News

Related Stories