Breitbart Business Digest: How High-Skill Visa Programs Hurt American Tech Workers

Breitbart
Original Story by Breitbart
November 16, 2026
Breitbart Business Digest: How High-Skill Visa Programs Hurt American Tech Workers

The piece argues that the United States’ temporary high-skill visa programs, notably the H-1B, created a long-running gap between promised shortages and the reality of the domestic workforce. A Harvard study is cited showing substantial earnings declines for native workers in computing and engineering due to competition from temporary workers, while foreign hires gained access to higher-paying roles. The analysis describes a large, indirect transfer of income—from American technologists to visa workers and their employers—without a net societal gain. As AI automates coding, the article suggests the structural incentives that kept demand high for foreign labor may be unwinding. The piece frames the policy as a persistent labor-market tax on American tech workers, with the implication that reform could rebalance incentives for U.S. training and wages.

Dive Deeper:

  • The history notes the 1990 creation of the H-1B program with an initial cap of 65,000 for new hires, with extensions not counting against the cap, leading to potential aggregate headcounts well above the initial figure over time.

  • There is no official ongoing headcount for H-1B workers, with estimates ranging from about 583,000 in 2019 to as high as 730,000 per a pro-immigration group, highlighting opaque tracking.

  • Harvard economist George Borjas finds that temporary high-skill immigration has depressed earnings for Americans in computing and related fields, with 2024 losses around 15.8% for computing majors and 17.2% for electrical/computer engineering.

  • Borjas’ analysis segments graduates into 60 groups by major and attainment, showing the largest exposure to temporary workers doubled from 28 to 56 per 100 in the top third of affected groups between 2012 and 2024.

  • Among the most exposed, native bachelor’s and master’s graduates in science and engineering saw average real-terms pay declines around 7% from 2012 to 2024, while less exposed groups rose by about 6%.

  • Overall, Borjas estimates a net societal loss of about $47 billion annually across roughly 13 million Americans in medium- to high-exposure groups, depicting the visa program as an income redistribution mechanism rather than a net gain.

  • The article argues that reduced rewards for coding work dampened American entry into the field, ensuring ongoing demand for extensions, even as AI accelerates automation of coding tasks.

Latest News

Related Stories