Climate Loophole In Bipartisan Deal Could Let Next Administration Kill Pipelines, Conservatives Warn

The Daily Caller
Original Story by The Daily Caller
November 21, 2026
Climate Loophole In Bipartisan Deal Could Let Next Administration Kill Pipelines, Conservatives Warn

A lame-duck Senate approved the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act by a 62-33 vote to overhaul pipelines permitting, drawing warnings from Heritage Foundation analysts that the bill’s revised exceptions could let future administrations revoke already approved pipelines over health or environmental concerns. The Nov. 7 rewrite added language tying a broad health/environment safeguard to a new exception, prompting debate over whether agencies could act on new information to halt projects. Critics argue this could undermine permit certainty and invite politically charged reversals, while supporters say it balances certainty with crisis responses. The bill now moves to the House, where outcomes remain uncertain and debate continues over how it would apply to major projects like natural gas pipelines.

Dive Deeper:

  • Heritage Foundation analysts Jason Hayes and Sarah Wagoner warned that the November rewrite could empower future administrations to challenge approved pipelines by arguing immediate harm to health or the environment, potentially reversing prior permit decisions.

  • The Nov. 7 manager’s amendment added a health and environment exception to permit certainty, allowing agencies to intervene if new information signals immediate, specific, urgent harm, alongside a separate exception for actions under applicable laws or regulations.

  • Critics like Hayes compared the risk to the Keystone XL reversal, noting how presidential actions can erase permits after initial approvals, which they say undermines investment certainty.

  • Supporters including energy policy experts from the Cato Institute argued the bill seeks a balance between permit certainty and allowing action in real crises, stressing the need to avoid nebulous or politically motivated revocations.

  • Environmental group Earthjustice praised the addition as a positive step but warned the word ‘immediate’ could still limit or complicate certain health risk considerations, potentially reducing long-term certainty.

  • The bill’s passage was part of a broader negotiation among four negotiators, with 14 Democrats and independent Sen. Angus King joining 47 Republicans in support, while a small number of Republicans opposed it; the House still needs to weigh the measure.

Latest News

Related Stories