Every 2026 Game of the Year Nominee, Ranked

Collider
Original Story by Collider
November 19, 2026
Every 2026 Game of the Year Nominee, Ranked

A year-end ranking of the six Game of the Year nominees for 2026, framed as a momentum-driven awards race. The list sparked debate over inclusions and omissions, with Grand Theft Auto VI emerging as the favored, if controversial, front-runner despite not yet being released at nomination time. Other contenders—Phantom Blade Zero, 007: First Light, Control Resonant, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake, and Resident Evil Requiem—are praised for their innovations but scrutinized for varied reasons, from genre shifts to remake safety. The piece positions the award as a culmination of gameplay, design, and reception, while signaling anticipation for December’s decision and the year ahead.

Dive Deeper:

  • Phantom Blade Zero is highlighted as a late-year surprise that earned a Game of the Year nomination. It is praised for fast-paced combat, choreography, and replayability, but is rated last among the six when stacked against its peers, especially by soulslike enthusiasts who note genre fatigue. The nomination is acknowledged as deserved, even if it doesn’t measure up to others in the list.

  • 007: First Light is described as an acclaimed Bond-era action title that blends blockbuster energy with spycraft. It follows Bond’s early years on a globe-trotting mission to earn 00 status, featuring a mix of stylish set pieces and mentor-driven arcs. Despite strong fan interest, it stands out as a divisive pick with many predicting the nominees correctly, yet some fans omitting it from personal lists.

  • Control Resonant marks Remedy Entertainment’s continued presence at the Game Awards and is framed as a bold, original entry. The game shifts to melee-focused action RPG mechanics set in a surreal Manhattan, with a Metacritic score around the low-80s cited to explain mixed reception. Critics praise its risk-taking and design depth, even as some players preferred a more traditional path.

  • The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake is positioned as the most controversial nominee due to its near-1:1 remake approach rather than a new project. It is noted for polish, art direction, and fluid controls that elevate an almost thirty-year-old classic, earning it the year’s second-highest Metacritic standing and sparking debate over whether a remake deserved nomination over newer titles.

  • Resident Evil Requiem is framed around its 30th anniversary aura, featuring dual protagonists Grace Ashcroft and Leon S. Kennedy in a hotel-set conspiracy narrative. Its gameplay blends stealth, puzzle-solving, and intense combat, with standout atmosphere aided by sound design. The piece argues it was a near-lock for the award, but was arguably surpassed by the year’s most anticipated title.

  • Grand Theft Auto VI is cast as the undeniable favorite to win, due to Rockstar’s influence and a long 13-year wait for a new entry in the series. The setting returns to Vice City with two protagonists, Lucia and Jason, navigating a chaotic underworld. Although highly acclaimed, its nomination sparked controversy because the game wasn’t publicly available at the time of the announcement, yet reviews have positioned it as a potential record-setter with a near-perfect Metacritic profile.

Latest News

Related Stories