'Hawks Flying in Formation': Judge Allows Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against RAM Giants to Proceed
A federal judge let a proposed class-action alleging price-fixing by the three largest DRAM makers move forward, rejecting that the plaintiffs merely echoed a 2018 antitrust case and emphasizing that parallel conduct is unlikely to be harmless. The suit, brought by 17 plaintiffs, contends DRAM prices spiked dramatically in a single year, driven by coordinated supply restrictions. The defendants—Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix—argue the actions were independent strategic choices in a high-demand market. The court set an early schedule with a December 7 response deadline and a January 2027 case-management conference, marking the case for continued litigation.
Dive Deeper:
The case, brought by 17 individuals and small businesses, accuses Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix of colluding to restrict DRAM supply and inflate prices.
Judge Noël Wise denied a motion to dismiss, stating the defendants’ alignment is not readily explained as ordinary competitive behavior and noting the comment that their conduct resembled hawks flying in formation.
Plaintiffs point to four parallel moves between late 2022 and spring 2023: production cuts, a shift toward high-bandwidth memory, winding down of DDR4 production, and a lack of expanded manufacturing capacity during rising prices.
Additional supporting factors cited by plaintiffs include stricter customer vetting, reluctance to sign long-term DRAM contracts, Micron’s shutdown of Crucial, and prior industry price-fixing history.
Defendants contend the actions reflect independent business decisions in a highly concentrated market, arguing that firms simply reacted to common market pressures to maximize revenue.
SK hynix is already under a separate shareholder investigation related to its practices, adding to the regulatory scrutiny surrounding the case.
With the denial of the motion to dismiss, the parties must respond by December 7, and a case-management conference is planned for January 2027 to address procedural matters.