He expected a small-business loan. It turned out to be a trap
A small-business owner’s pursuit of a $750,000 funding line through a broker led him into a high-cost, largely unregulated merchant cash advance system. After paying daily fees for 30 days, the promised credit never materialized, triggering years of debt, foreclosure, and a protracted legal fight against the funder and brokers. The saga highlights how MCAs promise fast capital but impose steep, opaque costs and aggressive collections, with few safeguards for first-time borrowers. Amid mounting losses and personal sacrifice, the entrepreneur fights to recover what he believes is evidence of fraud, while policy efforts move slowly toward tighter oversight. The case illustrates broader risks for small businesses and a push for industry self-correction and regulation going forward.
Dive Deeper:
Vahe Shahinian, an Armenian American entrepreneur, was offered a $750,000 line of credit for his events business in 2019. He accepted a condition that required daily payments of $3,600 for 30 days before accessing the rest of the funds, but the line of credit never arrived and his life began a long, escalating financial struggle.
Shahinian ultimately received $228,000 instead of the promised $250,000, with the remainder taken as an upfront fee common to merchant cash advances. He allocated nearly half the funds to secure the daily payments, while the rest funded venues, tours, and other investments, which did not yield expected returns.
Merchant cash advances are pitched as fast, high-risk funding with fees ranging from 25% to 200% or more, and they operate largely outside traditional lending rules because they are treated as purchases of future sales rather than loans. The industry relies on brokers and often withdrawals from borrowers’ bank accounts, creating a system with little licensing or oversight in many cases.
EIN Cap, a Wall Street–based funder, argued it never promised loans or lines of credit, only a merchant cash advance delivered by brokers who allegedly made promises. Shahinian filed suit in 2019; the case against EIN Cap remained ongoing after multiple delays, while he had already settled with brokers years earlier.
Within weeks of taking additional MCAs to cover costs for his tour, Shahinian accrued more than $1 million in debt to friends and family, leading to a foreclosure of his home and a major shift back to basic operations, with his accounts drained and his social circle shrinking.
Beyond his personal losses, Shahinian connected with about 700 small-business owners who had been sued by the funders for debt collection; he ultimately sought more than $5 million in recovery, arguing the deals constituted fraud and a coercive ‘carroting’ tactic that lured first-time borrowers into unsustainable financing.
California and some states have started requiring clearer disclosures and licensing for MCA funders and brokers, with California proposing licensing and background checks starting in 2028, signaling momentum toward stronger oversight despite the ongoing legal battles and ongoing industry disputes.