How lessons from football history reveal the real reason behind Manchester City’s decline

Independent
Original Story by Independent
November 22, 2026
How lessons from football history reveal the real reason behind Manchester City’s decline

Manchester City’s downturn is explained by on-field factors rather than sanctions, as Enzo Maresca struggles to stabilise a revamped squad. The team has been leaking goals, with no clean sheets in nine straight matches, and lacks midfield control and defensive chemistry after a costly rebuild. The decline began before Guardiola’s departure, with heavy spending and an aging core that relied on a few stars for inspiration. The broader pattern mirrors historical cycles in English football, suggesting success can falter when a dynasty ages or rivals rise; the future hinges on whether City can recalibrate or face a harsher punishment that could redefine their status.

Dive Deeper:

  • City’s struggles are framed as a football problem, not solely a regulatory one, with Maresca emphasizing defensive fragility and tactical instability after a summer overhaul.

  • Key issues include a lack of clean sheets (nine consecutive matches without one), midfields that exert less control, and an uncertain best back four under the new manager.

  • There is heavy reliance on Erling Haaland for goals, while other attackers such as Elliot Anderson, Iliman Ndiaye, and Rayan Cherki have not delivered consistently.

  • Historical parallels are drawn to Liverpool and others who started strong but declined, illustrating that early success can expose underlying flaws that worsen over time.

  • City’s spending remains massive (roughly £450m in fees this summer and about £900m across the last four windows), yet the return is uncertain if the squad cannot sustain balance and cohesion.

  • The piece argues that the true explanation for the downturn is the football performance itself, not just sanctions, and notes the potential end of an era if a major points deduction is imposed.

  • Looking ahead, the outcome depends on whether Maresca can stabilise the lineup, rebuild chemistry, and fend off a looming sanction that could redefine City’s future trajectory.

Latest News

Related Stories