NFL midseason surprises: 6 teams and players nobody saw coming

SB Nation
Original Story by SB Nation
November 11, 2026
NFL midseason surprises: 6 teams and players nobody saw coming

Midseason, several NFL teams and players have defied expectations, creating a vivid mix of surprises across the league. Cleveland sits at 5-4 and in the playoff hunt despite being projected for the draft’s lower tier, with wins mostly against weaker opponents overshadowing deeper concerns. New York’s Giants, undermanned by injuries, sit atop the NFC East at 5-2-1, showcasing resilience despite missing key starters. Jacksonville has emerged as a top-tier contender, fueled by a league-best point differential and strong turnover plus a revamped defense. Minnesota relies on a stout defense to mask offensive uncertainties, while rookies Emmett Johnson and Zakee Wheatley have stood out for Kansas City and Carolina, respectively, signaling fresh momentum for their teams.

Dive Deeper:

  • Cleveland’s 5-4 record has them just outside the playoffs at midseason, despite owning both its own first-round pick and a Rams’ first due to a high-profile trade. The team’s metrics suggest a gap between actual wins and underlying efficiency, with Offensive and Defensive EPA placing them near the bottom; wins have come mainly against teams with losing records, prompting questions about sustainability.

  • New York’s Giants have defied preseason projections by leading the NFC East at 5-2-1, even after losing their starting quarterback early and having a key back inactive in Week 9. The success hinges on resilience and depth, with a tougher slate looming against Jacksonville, San Francisco, Seattle, and a pivotal Week 17 showdown with Dallas that could decide the division.

  • Jacksonville has surged to elite status through nine weeks, leading the league in point differential (+108) and turnover margin (+9). The defense has improved notably after trading for Jessie Bates III, and while there were losses to Denver and Houston, their overall performance positions them as a high-ceiling playoff contender rather than merely playoff-caliber.

  • Minnesota is buoyed by a top-tier defense that masks offensive questions, especially at quarterback, leaving the team with a surprising playoff outlook despite concerns about the offense’s consistency. Analysts who favored the Vikings cited Brian Flores’s schematic prowess as a key driver of their early-season success.

  • Emmett Johnson (KC) has emerged as a distinctive playmaker, combining 26 rushing attempts for 111 yards with 237 receiving yards and a touchdown on 14 catches, including a 73-yard score. His versatility adds a dynamic element to Kansas City’s backfield and could trigger an expanded role as the season progresses.

  • Zakee Wheatley (Carolina) has made rapid positive impressions from the Penn State drafting class, totaling 27 tackles and forcing a fumble, plus an interception of Jordan Love in Week 8. Despite occasional snaps reductions under interim coordinator Todd Walsh, Wheatley remains one of the season’s notable breakout defenders.

  • Overall, the midseason surge of these teams and players signals a league where early expectations are being recalibrated, with questions about sustainability and the potential for continued momentum shaping the second half of the season.

Latest News

Related Stories