Rachael Leigh Cook Shares Which ‘She’s All That’ Costar She Wants as Her Next Hallmark Leading Man

Us Weekly
Original Story by Us Weekly
November 22, 2026
Rachael Leigh Cook Shares Which ‘She’s All That’ Costar She Wants as Her Next Hallmark Leading Man

Rachael Leigh Cook revealed in an exclusive interview that her preferred Hallmark leading man from her film She’s All That would be Dulé Hill, praising his romantic energy and referencing their prior work together. She also suggested Tamara Mello as a potential co-star and confirmed ongoing conversations with Freddie Prinze Jr. about a future collaboration, though not necessarily for Hallmark. Meanwhile, Cook stars in Double Booked for the Holidays, which premieres on Hallmark Channel on November 22 and streams on Hallmark+ the next day, portraying twins who run a Welsh bookstore while unraveling a long-meturner mystery and romance. She also teased a separate project, The Christmas Affair, with Prinze, as part of her ongoing post-90s film reunion plans. The overall arc centers on cross-network partnerships, reinvigorating familiar collaborations, and holiday-themed storytelling with a mix of nostalgia and new dynamics.

Dive Deeper:

  • Cook names Dulé Hill, known for Holes and his overall romantic energy, as her ideal Hallmark leading man, describing him as incredibly handsome and a strong fit for a Hallmark-style romance. She notes their prior connection through She’s All That and later appearances on Psych, underscoring a natural on-screen chemistry.

  • She also mentions Tamara Mello, her former tormentor in She’s All That, as someone she’d like to cast opposite her in a Hallmark project, emphasizing their friendship and Mello’s comedic timing.

  • Freddie Prinze Jr. emerges as another potential co-star, with Cook indicating they’ve discussed reuniting, though she cautions that their next project might not be for Hallmark, to avoid distraction from current plans.

  • Cook is currently promoting Double Booked for the Holidays, in which she plays twins who run a bookstore in Hay-on-Wye during Christmas while uncovering a decade-old mystery and navigating two romance threads.

  • The film Double Booked for the Holidays premieres on Hallmark Channel on Sunday, November 22, at 8 p.m. ET and will stream on Hallmark+ the following day, marking a continued holiday-season rollout strategy for the network.

  • Cook alludes to ongoing and future collaborations, including The Christmas Affair with Freddie Prinze Jr., describing it as a project that has been discussed and is in the works, signaling a broader plan to rebuild a 1990s-era star cohort for new projects.

  • Throughout the interview, Cook emphasizes seizing opportunities and embracing unexpected chances in her career, encapsulated by her remark about saying yes to unique chances when they arise.

Latest News

Related Stories