Trump calls the U.S.-Canada border an 'artificial line.' That's not entirely true
Context:
During a meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, President Trump described the U.S.-Canada border as an 'artificially drawn line' and suggested it should be erased, proposing Canada could be the 51st U.S. state. Trump's comments have been criticized for downplaying the deep historical and geographical significance of the border, which was established through a series of treaties between 1783 and 1925 and follows the 49th parallel. The border is the world's longest international boundary and involves complex historical negotiations, including considerations for river systems and Indigenous territories. While Parmenter, a history professor, acknowledges the border is a human construct, he emphasizes its legitimacy and real-world implications. In light of Trump's tariffs and rhetoric, there is increased Canadian awareness and concern about the border, though experts like Parmenter advocate for thoughtful negotiations rather than drastic changes.
Dive Deeper:
President Trump, during a meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, called the U.S.-Canada border an 'artificially drawn line' and expressed views of potentially erasing it to make Canada a part of the United States, sparking criticism and political tension.
The U.S.-Canada border, largely following the 49th parallel, was established through treaties from 1783 to 1925, including the Treaty of Paris and the Convention of 1818, and is the longest international boundary in the world, stretching 5,525 miles.
History professor Jon Parmenter critiques Trump's remarks, highlighting the border's importance and history, noting that it is indeed a man-made construct but not illegitimate or irrelevant, as it carries significant implications for those living near it.
The choice of the 49th parallel was strategic, with the British aiming to protect the northern fur trade and the U.S. seeking land for agricultural expansion, leading to a division based on river systems and watersheds.
The border was shaped without considering geographical formations or Indigenous territories, impacting communities like the Mohawk in Akwesasne, whose lands were bisected by the boundary.
Over time, the border evolved through numerous treaties and agreements, resulting in diverse monitoring levels today, from heavily patrolled sections to remote areas marked by monuments, managed by the International Boundary Commission.
Heightened Canadian awareness about the border arises from Trump's tariffs and annexation rhetoric, though experts advocate for calm and constructive negotiations to manage the border effectively and maintain good relations.