News Page

Main Content

Giants-Saints trade proposal replaces Derek Carr with $8 million quarterback

The Sporting News's profile
The Sporting News
4h ago
Giants-Saints trade proposal replaces Derek Carr with $8 million quarterback

Context:

Following Derek Carr's unexpected retirement, the New Orleans Saints are considering their quarterback options, including Tyler Shough, a second-round pick. There is speculation about a potential reunion with Jameis Winston, who previously played for the Saints and is now a backup with the New York Giants. The Giants, having drafted Jaxson Dart and signed Russell Wilson, may consider trading Winston if Dart shows promising development during training camp. However, the likelihood of a trade is low as the Saints have recently invested in Shough. Ryan Novozinsky suggests Winston could be a valuable bridge option for the Saints, given his familiarity with the team and recent experience as a starter for the Browns.

Dive Deeper:

  • Derek Carr's sudden retirement has left the New Orleans Saints in need of a quarterback solution, with Tyler Shough, a recent second-round draft pick, among the current options.

  • Jameis Winston, who has past experience with the Saints and is currently a backup for the New York Giants, is speculated to be a potential candidate for a return to New Orleans.

  • The Giants' recent quarterback moves, including drafting Jaxson Dart and signing Russell Wilson, might allow for a Winston trade if Dart develops well by training camp.

  • Despite these possibilities, a trade for Winston seems unlikely since the Saints have just invested in a young quarterback, Tyler Shough, who will soon be 26.

  • Ryan Novozinsky points out that Winston could serve as an effective transitional player for the Saints due to his previous tenure with the team and his recent starting role with the Browns.

  • The New Orleans Saints are dealing with the aftermath of Derek Carr's shocking retirement.

  • With the veteran now out of the picture, the Saints are likely to move forward with their current group of quarterbacks, including second-round pick Tyler Shough.

  • However, there's a small chance the Saints look to reunite with a fan favorite if they're searching for more competition at the position.

  • Though he just signed a two-year deal with the New York Giants this offseason, Ryan Novozinsky of NJ.com believes the Saints could come calling about Jameis Winston.

  • "It makes sense for New Orleans to take another shot on Winston, who played there from 2020-2023, starting 10 games over four seasons. The 31-year-old vet — who started seven games with the Browns last season — would be the best bridge option they could hope for right now," Novozinsky wrote.

  • Winston is currently the backup to starter Russell Wilson in the Giants quarterback room. However, New York also traded up to grab Jaxson Dart out of Ole Miss with the No. 25 overall pick.

  • Winston was the first quarterback the Giants added to the room this offseason. A week later, they signed Wilson to a one-year deal and then grabbed Dart in the draft.

  • If the Giants are comfortable enough with Dart's development going into training camp, it's not outside the realm of possibilities for New York to part ways with Winston if they get enough value in a trade.

  • However, it seems unlikely a deal will come to fruition given the fact that New Orleans just spent a second-round pick on a rookie quarterback who will turn 26 years old at the beginning of the season.

Latest Sports

Related Stories