News Page

Main Content

Inside Paul DePodesta's confusing legacy with the Cleveland Browns

Sports Illustrated's profile
Original Story by Sports Illustrated
November 9, 2025
Inside Paul DePodesta's confusing legacy with the Cleveland Browns

Context:

Paul DePodesta's tenure as Chief Strategy Officer for the Cleveland Browns has been met with mixed opinions, culminating in his recent departure to become the president of baseball operations for the Colorado Rockies. DePodesta's arrival in 2016 coincided with a strategic rebuild that included drafting notable players, yet the team's performance has remained dismal, finishing with a 3-14 record last season. His ambiguous role within the organization has fueled both criticism and confusion, with fans questioning his contributions and decision-making influence. As the Browns continue to struggle, DePodesta's exit raises questions about the future direction of the franchise and the potential shift in leadership dynamics under owner Jimmy Haslam. Ultimately, his legacy in Cleveland is one of uncertainty amid ongoing team struggles.

Dive Deeper:

  • DePodesta joined the Browns in 2016 and oversaw a two-year period where the team had a record of 1-31, which was part of a planned rebuild strategy.

  • Under his leadership, the Browns drafted key players like Myles Garrett, Denzel Ward, and Baker Mayfield, yet the team's overall performance has not significantly improved.

  • Despite his high salary, DePodesta's exact influence on scouting, drafting, and personnel decisions was often unclear, leading to fans questioning his effectiveness.

  • His departure could impact the coaching staff, particularly if he was a supporter of head coach Kevin Stefanski, potentially triggering further changes within the organization.

  • DePodesta's legacy is characterized by a lack of transparency; he will leave the team without a playoff win in nearly a decade, marking a challenging period for the franchise.

  • The Browns finished the previous season with one of the worst records in the NFL and are still managing a problematic contract, complicating their rebuilding efforts.

  • His move to the Rockies is viewed as a significant shift, potentially setting off a chain reaction of changes within the Browns' front office.

Latest Sports

Related Stories