News Page

Main Content

Midseason Mayhem: NFL Power Rankings at the Halfway Mark

Hunter Tierney 's profile
By Hunter Tierney
November 6, 2025
Midseason Mayhem: NFL Power Rankings at the Halfway Mark

Parity’s running the show this year, and it’s beautiful chaos. We’re halfway through the NFL season, and it feels like every week rewrites what we think we know. Week 9 didn’t clear anything up either—four of the Vegas Super Bowl favorites (Chiefs, Colts, Packers, Lions) all lost, and suddenly the standings look like someone hit shuffle on Madden’s franchise mode. That’s what makes this season fun: not just figuring out who’s good right now, but who can keep climbing.

That’s the lens here — teams that are built to scale. Can you win on early downs? Can you finish drives when it matters? Can your defense travel when it gets cold and ugly in November? Those are the questions that separate contenders from pretenders.

1) Los Angeles Rams (6–2)

When the Rams are clicking, everything looks effortless. They’ll pound you with duo and zone runs until the linebackers start creeping up, and then—boom—Stafford’s hitting crossers behind them. Week 9 against New Orleans was the perfect example: a 34–10 cruise that never felt competitive. They rushed for over 170 yards, hit chunk plays to Puka Nacua and Davante Adams, and made it all look like a well‑oiled machine. That’s the identity Sean McVay’s been chasing since this retool began — bully you early, hit you deep later.

Matthew Stafford’s been on a heater, and it’s not just the stat line that tells the story. Sure, he’s got 16 touchdowns and zero picks in his last five games, but it’s the command that stands out. The ball’s coming out fast, the reads are sharp, and he’s punishing defenses no matter what they try to throw at him. The biggest difference this year? The little things. They’re winning on first down, staying ahead of the sticks, and letting McVay keep his full playbook open.

On defense, this team doesn’t need smoke and mirrors — they’re just beating people up front. Top‑five across most efficiency metrics, holding teams under 16 points a game, and generating pressure without blitzing and leaving their secondary out to dry. The front has already piled up 27 sacks by collapsing pockets, and the midseason pickup of Roger McCreary has given the secondary some much‑needed bite. The real tests are coming — they still have two against the Seahawks as well as the Lions and Bucs on the schedule — but right now this looks like a January offense paired with a defense built for bad weather. That’s a dangerous mix.

2) Detroit Lions (5–3)

Detroit Lions running back David Montgomery (5), left, and running back Jahmyr Gibbs (0) celebrates 38-30 win over Baltimore Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium in Baltimore, Md. on Monday, Sept. 22, 2025.
Credit: Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Lions are still every bit the contender they’ve looked like all year, even if that trip to Minnesota left a bruise. Yeah, a lot went wrong in that game — missed assignments, stalled drives, and some sloppy tackling — but one off Sunday doesn’t erase everything this team has shown through the first half of the season. When Detroit’s humming, there aren’t many teams that can hang with them. The offensive line has found its footing, Jahmyr Gibbs and David Montgomery keep finding ways to turn three-yard plays into seven, and Amon-Ra St. Brown is still a walking first down. Jared Goff’s comfort behind that front dictates everything, and when the pocket’s clean, this offense looks like a machine again.

Defensively, help is on the way. Getting guys healthy — from Brian Branch to the rotation up front — should make a noticeable difference. Aidan Hutchinson continues to anchor the identity of that group, wrecking pockets and forcing teams to alter their game plans around him. When they’re healthy and flying around, they can bully teams up front and play the brand of football Dan Campbell loves: physical, relentless, and unapologetic.

The schedule ahead isn’t doing them any favors — Philly, Green Bay, another match with the Vikings, and the Rams will be looking to make a statement against them — but there’s also not a roster in football that wants to see Detroit when it’s firing on all cylinders. They’ve got the coaching, the trenches, and the balance on both sides to go toe-to-toe with anyone. One bad week doesn’t change that. If anything, it’s the kind of loss that sharpens focus. Expect them to punch back hard.

3) Kansas City Chiefs (5–4)

I know this one might not be the most popular take, but I’m not hitting the panic button on Kansas City. Yeah, the Bills got them again in the regular season — it’s becoming a bit of a tradition at this point — but history’s shown that doesn’t really mean much come January. I don’t think this is the same kind of sluggish stretch we saw early in the year. This felt different. It felt like a team playing a little vanilla and keeping things close to the vest. Andy Reid’s been around too long to show his whole hand in Week 9 when there’s a real chance they’ll see Buffalo again in the playoffs.

They still need a reliable chain-mover on offense, someone who can consistently bail Mahomes out on third down without him needing to spin magic out of thin air. Rashee Rice is slowly becoming that guy, but it's not happening as fast as they'd like. But Travis Kelce's still got some in the tank when the lights are brightest, and counting on Mahomes to have another game where he plays this poorly would be a bad bet. The offensive line carousel and timing issues have made some of the passing concepts clunky, but the Chiefs are still generating opportunities — they’re just not finishing drives the way we’re used to. I expect that to change as Rice gets more comfortable in the offense.

This team’s been through too many of these midseason hiccups to overreact. Once they find that rhythm, no one adjusts and elevates like Mahomes and Reid when it matters most.

4) Philadelphia Eagles (6–2)

Sep 4, 2025; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (1) carries the ball against the Dallas Cowboys during the second quarter of the game at Lincoln Financial Field.
Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

The champs hit their bye week at the perfect time — beat up, a little uneven, but far from broken. Before the break, they steamrolled the Giants for 276 on the ground and four Hurts touchdowns, and it looked like the old Philly swagger was back. The season stats might not jump off the page — middle of the pack in both passing and rushing efficiency — but things have certainly been trending in the righ direction. Hurts’ run threat still freezes linebackers, the offensive line still bullies people, and when they’re staying ahead of the sticks, this unit can score in bunches.

Defensively, they’ve started to turn a corner too. The trade deadline moves showed they’re still all‑in on the window, and getting a guy like Jaire Alexander into the mix lets them dictate more matchups and play the aggressive, top‑down coverage that’s been missing at times this year. The tackling and communication have both been sharper over the last month, and if that trend holds, this defense starts to look a lot more like the one that pushed them to a Lombardi.

The real key now is consistency. Philly’s capable of flattening almost anyone when they play clean, but penalties and negative plays have been their worst enemy. The upcoming Monday night matchup with Green Bay should tell us a lot — if they can stay on schedule and let Hurts operate from structure, you’ll see the full Eagles offense again. Fall behind the chains, and the timing issues that have crept up could reappear. Either way, the bye came at the perfect time to reset and reload for the stretch run.

5) Tampa Bay Buccaneers (6–2)

The Bucs hit the bye week looking like a team held together by duct tape — and that’s not an insult, it’s a compliment. They’ve battled through injuries at nearly every skill position, and Baker Mayfield has still managed to keep the ship steady. He’s not putting up the video‑game numbers he was in the first few weeks, but 13 touchdowns to 2 picks is the kind of grown‑man football that wins divisions. This offense knows exactly what it is: a mix of play‑action, smart decisions, and Mayfield trusting his reads even as his receivers rotate in and out. When they’re clicking, it’s boundary shots, designed rollouts, and just enough attitude to keep defenses honest.

Todd Bowles’ defense deserves a lot more love than it gets. They’ve been patching holes up front and still limiting opponents to just over 15 points a game before the bye. Even without a fully healthy front, they’re staying disciplined in rush lanes and forcing quarterbacks into ugly throws. The disguise game has been on point too — mixing pressures, showing coverages late, and taking away the easy throws. It’s not flashy, but it’s effective, and that’s Bowles’ brand of football.

Tampa’s two‑game cushion in the South gives them a little breathing room, but they’re looking for more than a division title this year. If they keep playing mistake‑free ball and get some guys back offensively, this goes from a hot start to a real puch for the NFC crown. Health is still the headline, but there’s a toughness and chemistry here that feels real.

6) New England Patriots (7–2)

Oct 5, 2025; Orchard Park, New York, USA; New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye (10) and wide receiver Stefon Diggs (8) walks off the field against the Buffalo Bills after the game at Highmark Stadium.
Credit: Gregory Fisher-Imagn Images

Mike Vrabel came in preaching complementary football, and he’s delivered exactly that. The Patriots are winning with an old-school formula that works: the best run defense in football, a top‑six scoring unit overall, and an offense that stays on schedule and tends to avoid the self-inflicted wounds that bury bad teams. Drake Maye’s been everything they hoped for and more — steady, confident, and efficient. Completing a league-best 74% of his passes and a mind-boggling 68% of his deep passes has him firmly in the MVP conversation.

New England’s also nailing the little things, and they're back to playing situational football better than their opponents — the third downs, red-zone trips, and two-minute drills that separate good teams from great ones.

The question now is whether this offense can keep generating chunk plays without losing its discipline. They don’t need highlight-reel bombs three times a drive; they just need to continue being efficient when they do, and take better care of the football. Games like the five-turnover Steeler loss stick in your memory.

The schedule gets lighter from here, and until the Bills prove otherwise, the AFC East runs through Foxborough. Vrabel’s got them playing the exact type of football we all expected when he got the job — and Patriot fans wouldn't have it any other way.

7) Buffalo Bills (6–2)

The Bills’ win over Kansas City was impressive, no doubt — but it also feels like its own separate chapter in what’s been a weird, uneven season. Buffalo’s had a few real clunkers in the first half — games where the offense sputtered, the defense gave up too many chunk plays, or the focus just wasn’t there. So while beating the Chiefs is always a big deal, it doesn’t suddenly erase the inconsistency that’s defined them so far.

The thing about Buffalo right now is that they can beat anyone in the league on a good day, but they can just as easily lose to anyone on a bad one. That volatility is what makes them both dangerous and frustrating. Josh Allen still flashes MVP-level brilliance, and when James Cook is rolling, the offense feels unstoppable. But we’ve also seen them stall out for quarters or halves at a time, and the defense — banged up as it’s been — hasn’t always been able to bail them out. They’ll need to find a middle ground if they want to stabilize down the stretch.

And the road ahead isn’t easy. The Patriots are red hot and Buffalo’s schedule doesn’t offer many breathers. Don’t get me wrong — the win over Kansas City matters, especially given the rivalry and the confidence it brings — but I'm just not convinced that's the team we're going to see week in and week out.

8) Indianapolis Colts (7–2)

Oct 26, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor (28) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during the third quarter against the Tennessee Titans at Lucas Oil Stadium.
Credit: Robert Goddin-Imagn Images

It’s getting harder and harder to deny what the Colts are doing every week. Even with the loss in Pittsburgh, this group looks like one of the most complete and confident teams in football. Sure, five Daniel Jones turnovers will tank just about any game plan, but even with all of that, they still had a chance late — that’s how good this team’s floor has become. The Colts got away from who they are in that one, only running the ball 19 times, and it showed. When Jonathan Taylor sets the tone and the RPO and play‑action game builds off it, this offense looks like a one‑seed. When they don’t, things start to unravel.

The defense, though, deserves credit for holding everything together. They only allowed 38 rushing yards, sacked Rodgers three times, and forced multiple field goals off short fields instead of giving up seven. That’s how a good team survives a bad day. The only real concern was attrition at corner — but they addressed that in a huge way by acquiring Sauce Gardner at the trade deadline.

What they’ve done so far has been spectacular. It’s not often you see a new quarterback and a retooled roster mesh this quickly, and every week it’s feeling more real. The lingering hesitation is whether Daniel Jones can keep this up without more games like the one in Pittsburgh. If anything’s going to derail this run, it’s that — him reverting to the guy we saw the last two years in New York. Can’t have any more of those. But if he stays clean, the Colts are absolutely for real.

9) Green Bay Packers (5–2–1)

Losing as a double-digit favorite at home to Carolina is a gut punch, and the Tucker Kraft injury twists the knife. He was the glue in a lot of their offensive concepts—YAC routes, seams, third-down options—and losing that reliability hurts.

The bigger concern right now is the defense. Teams are content to run right at Green Bay and shorten the game. Give up 4.3 yards a carry for a month, and you’re living in play-action hell, constantly chasing third-and-shorts. That’s how games the Packers should win become coin flips.

We said earlier the Bills are a team that could beat anyone and lose to anyone — well, the Packers have proven that’s exactly who they are again and again. One week, they look like a contender; the next, they look completely out of sync. That unpredictability makes it hard to trust them in the big moments. You just never know which version of this team is going to show up.

LaFleur’s catching some heat, some fair and some overblown, but the bones are still there: creative motion, layered route concepts, a QB who can make throws off-platform and push tempo. They just need to tighten up in the red zone and stop beating themselves early in drives. If they — and Love in particular — can find some more consistency, they’ve got everything else they need to hang with anyone.

10) Pittsburgh Steelers (5–3)

Sep 7, 2025; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver Ben Skowronek (15) celebrates a touchdown with quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) during the first quarter against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium.
Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

The Steelers play a different brand of football this season — heavy on field position and getting the ball out quickly, while the defense relies on turnovers to cover up the yards they continue to give up — and the Colts win was on brand. They flipped the game with takeaways (six total) and held the league’s leading rusher to just 45 yards. When this defense forces long-yardage downs, Tomlin’s crew thrives on disguise and pressure.

There’s a lot to like about this team and the way they play in spurts — tough, physical, and opportunistic — but they’re another group battling serious consistency issues. The volatility is real: when the turnovers don’t come, the points allowed per drive spike, and the offense still struggles to pick up the slack. Rodgers has been efficient and decisive, but rarely explosive — good enough to grind out wins in the fall, but not always the gear you need when chasing a team down two scores in January.

The age across the roster doesn’t help either. Some of these vets can still bring it, but it’s tough to count on them holding up through the stretch. That makes this team hard to fully trust in big moments — you never quite know which version you’re getting.

11) Seattle Seahawks (6–2)

I really like this Seahawks team as a whole — they’re deep, balanced, and play with the kind of physical edge that travels. Adding Rasheed Shaheed at the deadline was one of those under‑the‑radar moves that fits perfectly with what they do. Defensively, they’ve been elite for most of the year, disguising coverages and forcing offenses to earn every inch. Mike Macdonald has them humming, and that’s not a fluke.

The question, though, is Sam Darnold. He’s played some solid football, but until he proves he can deliver in those big, late‑season, high‑pressure moments, it’s tough to fully buy in. He’s burned teams before with inconsistency, and even with all the talent around him, you just have to see it to believe it. Still, when this roster is clicking, they look like a legit contender — the kind that can make noise in January if the quarterback holds steady.

12) Denver Broncos (7–2)

Oct 5, 2025; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Denver Broncos quarterbacks Bo Nix (10) and Jarrett Stidham (8) and Sam Ehlinger (4) run from the tunnel for action against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field.
Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images

I don’t totally believe in this offense yet, but man, that defense is nasty. The Broncos might not be explosive on offense, but they’re efficient enough when it matters, and that defense could drag this team farther than anyone expects. Pat Surtain II being out changes matchup math against WR1s. You can still win with rush/coverage synergy, but the margin gets thinner.

Bo Nix has been streaky — he’ll look surgical for a drive and then miss the easy throw the next — but he’s handled crunch‑time moments well, which gives them a chance every week.

Sean Payton’s done a nice job of simplifying things for him, and that’s helped keep the floor high even when the offense sputters. Still, they’re not quite top‑tier in the AFC offensively; you can just feel the limitations when they face the elite teams. But with that defense locking teams down and creating chaos up front, Denver’s the kind of group that can win a lot of ugly games down the stretch. 

13) Baltimore Ravens (3–5)

The version we saw against Miami is the version everyone’s afraid of. Lamar looked fresh — four touchdown tosses — and Derrick Henry’s presence loaded the boxes up front. That’s when the Ravens’ pass game becomes easy: linebackers step, safeties cheat, and the crossers get daylight.

Defensively, the last three weeks have looked like a correction: 13 points a game allowed and a lot less freebies downfield. The Dre’Mont Jones addition gives them another interior body, which keeps the disguises intact without selling out to blitz.

Yeah, the start was bad — there’s no way around that — but we’ve seen this movie before. When this team gets hot, it can happen fast, and if they hit that stride again, look out. The reason I can’t push them higher right now is the hole they dug early. One or two slip‑ups or a key injury and that uphill climb gets steep again. Still, the ceiling is right there. If Lamar and that defense keep playing clean football, this is a team that can still contend for the whole AFC.

14) Los Angeles Chargers (6–3)

Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert (10) looks to pass the ball during a game against the New York Giants at MetLife Stadium, Sep 28, 2025, East Rutherford, NJ, USA.
Credit: Yannick Peterhans / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

This is the weirdest 6–3 in football: an offense that can look like a buzzsaw for a quarter, a defense that’ll play lights‑out for 50 minutes, and special teams that occasionally tries to spot the opponent 14. The Titans game had all of it—allowed a punt return TD and a pick‑six, then calmly smothered Tennessee’s offense to 206 yards and 1‑for‑9 on thirds.

Justin Herbert’s having a really nice season — efficient, confident, and tough under pressure — but the team around him can’t seem to put all the pieces together at the same time. The defense has quietly been very good, limiting explosive plays and generating consistent pressure, but when the offense goes cold, it’s usually at the worst times.

The Joe Alt injury hurts; with him, Herbert looks surgical, without him, the sacks and stalled drives pile up. They’ve got the talent and coaching to be dangerous, but until they play a full four quarters on both sides of the ball, they’ll keep flirting with mediocrity instead of owning their ceiling.

15) Minnesota Vikings (4–4)

That win in Detroit said a lot about who the Vikings can be when they’re healthy and focused. J.J. McCarthy’s stat line won’t blow anyone away, but the poise and confidence he’s shown in tight spots has made a real impression.

Kevin O’Connell kept things simple — bootlegs, play‑action, and clean reads — and it worked. The defense did the rest, wrecking protection calls and suffocating drives. When they look like that, you can see the makings of a playoff team.

But it’s still a matter of consistency. I really want to put them higher because I believe so strongly in McCarthy’s makeup and intangibles, but we just haven’t seen it week after week. He’s great in the big moments, but if the Vikings fall too far out of contention to even have those moments, that’s a problem.

If they can bottle what we saw against Detroit and bring that version out more often, they’re absolutely in the mix. If not, they’ll hover right where they are — dangerous, but unpredictable.

16) San Francisco 49ers (6–3)

Oct 2, 2025; Inglewood, California, USA; San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones (10) drops back to pass against the Los Angeles Rams in the second half at SoFi Stadium.
Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

It’s been a weird stretch for San Francisco without their starting quarterback, and even though Mac Jones has had his flashes, you can feel the difference in how this offense operates. There’s structure and some rhythm, but not the same steadiness that’s defined them at their best. Mac’s had a few hot games — like the one against the Giants — but relying on him for this long of a stretch makes you uneasy. You know he can run Kyle Shanahan’s system, but you also know what happens when defenses take away the first read and force him off-script.

Christian McCaffrey, though, continues to be the engine. He’s doing everything for this team and somehow still finding ways to keep them afloat. You worry about the workload, sure, but it’s hard to argue when the results are there. The real issue lies on the other side of the ball — that defense can only withstand so many injuries before the cracks start to show. Losing Nick Bosa and Fred Warner for the year is devastating, and while Robert Saleh's scheme keeps them competitive, it’s clear they’re one more big injury away from the wheels falling off.

17) Houston Texans (3–5)

It’s been a frustrating year in Houston. C.J. Stroud’s concussion sucked the air out of the offense against the Broncos. Mills has kept things functional, but this offense just doesn’t have that same juice without Stroud’s timing and processing speed. The receivers aren’t exactly world-beaters either — they’re solid but not scaring anyone — and the protection hasn’t done them any favors. Stroud’s been hit way too often, and that’s priority number one now: keeping him upright and healthy for the long haul.

Even with all that, I still fully believe in the third-year quarterback. He’s the kind you build around for a decade, but this might just be one of those years where the injuries and inconsistencies catch up. The defense is still legit — physical, fast, and fundamentally sound — and it keeps them in just about every game. But if the offense can’t finish drives or keep Stroud clean when he gets back, a couple more losses could have this group looking ahead to next season.

18) Chicago Bears (5–3)

Jan 5, 2025; Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) during the game against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field.
Credit: Jeff Hanisch-Imagn Images

The Bears have been a roller coaster this year, but not the fun kind. Their highs just aren’t all that high, and their lows are really ugly. That 47–42 win over Cincinnati was probably the best we’ve seen from them — Caleb Williams looked electric, the run game had real juice, and for a few hours, you could squint and see what this offense might become down the line. But then you remember it was against maybe the worst unit in the NFL, and then they’ll come out the next week and struggle to move the ball for three quarters.

Ben Johnson’s impact is real — more easy throws, better rhythm, a system that clearly fits the young QB — but it’s still early in the process. The defense can be opportunistic, forcing turnovers when it matters, but it also gives up massive chunk plays through the air. The balance just isn’t there yet. This isn’t a team one trade away from fixing things either. There’s talent, no doubt, but they’re still figuring out what it means to play competitive football every single week.

19) Dallas Cowboys (3–5–1)

The Cowboys are one of the strangest teams in the league right now. Their offense is good enough that you have to respect them every time they take the field — Dak’s throwing darts, the receivers are clicking, and when they get rolling, it looks effortless. But that defense? That’s a different story. It’s so bad right now that it completely undermines what the offense builds. You can trust this team to beat anyone on a given Sunday, but you can’t trust them to keep it up for any real stretch of games.

It's everything from red‑zone issues to blown assignments to stretches where it looks like they’ve never tackled before. The offense is explosive enough to mask some of it, but you just don’t win in the long run playing like this.

20) Jacksonville Jaguars (5–3)

Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence (16) celebrates his game-winning touchdown as tight end Hunter Long (84) reacts during the fourth quarter of an NFL football matchup at EverBank Stadium, Monday, Oct. 6, 2025, in Jacksonville, Fla. The Jacksonville Jaguars edged the Kansas City Chiefs 31-28.
Credit: Corey Perrine / Florida Times-Union

The Jaguars have been chasing the “next step” from Trevor Lawrence for years now, and we’re still waiting. Every so often, he’ll flash that generational talent — a side‑arm dart here, a perfect timing throw there — but outside of that, it's been average at best. The receivers can’t seem to separate and the play‑calling feels stuck between eras. They’re winning some close ones, sure, but none of it looks sustainable.

At this point, it’s fair to wonder if that leap ever really comes. Lawrence is still good enough to win you games, but the Jaguars need him to elevate them, not just manage. The defense is solid, still keeping them competitive week after week, but there’s only so much you can do when your offense keeps leaving points on the field. They’re not bad — just stuck. And “stuck” might be the worst place to be in the NFL.

21) Atlanta Falcons (3–5)

The Falcons are one of the hardest teams to figure out right now. I really believed in them early on — the roster looked solid, the system made sense, and Penix had the kind of arm talent that could stretch any defense. But right now, it’s tough to know where they're at. Penix doesn’t look broken, but his confidence looks rattled, and that’s concerning this early in his career. You can tell he’s pressing a little.

That’s a shame because there’s so much to like about this team when it’s right. The defense can flat-out play, the line can get after it, and when Bijan Robinson gets rolling, they can control games. But the margins are small. The missed field goals, penalties, and drive-killing sacks keep popping up. For now, it’s a lot of “what ifs.”

22) Cincinnati Bengals (3–6)

Oct 16, 2025; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals head coach Zac Taylor smiles at quarterback Joe Flacco (16) (obscured) as Flacco runs to the sideline during the fourth quarter against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Paycor Stadium.
Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

Most folks wrote this team off when Burrow went down and Jake Browning couldn’t move the offense. Then Joe Flacco showed up and completely changed the energy. It’s wild to say it, but this offense has been incredibly fun to watch the last few weeks. They’re attacking deep, spreading the ball around, and playing with tempo. The problem is — just like last year — the defense can’t stop getting in its own way. Missed tackles, bad angles, and too many big plays surrendered have turned shootouts into heartbreakers.

When Burrow gets healthy, this team will look different, but I don’t think they’ll be in the playoff picture by then — so there's a chance he doesn't get back on the field. Still, this Flacco-led offense can absolutely shake up the standings for other teams fighting for spots. Nobody wants to see them late in the year when they’re scoring like this.

23) Cleveland Browns (2–6)

Cleveland’s season has been a strange mix of dominance and dysfunction. Their defense is still elite — Myles Garrett and company can ruin game plans all by themselves — but the offense hasn't been able to carry their own weight. It’s jarring to see a defense this good paired with an offense that can’t even sustain drives. The passing game just hasn’t developed. Dillon Gabriel’s arm is fine, but the reads and decision-making just aren’t there yet.

24) Arizona Cardinals (3–5)

Dec 28, 2024; Inglewood, California, USA; Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray (1) reacts against the Los Angeles Rams in the second half at SoFi Stadium.
Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

Arizona just made headlines by announcing they're rolling with Jacoby Brissett after he beat the Cowboys on Monday night — even though Kyler Murray’s reportedly ready to go. That says a lot about where this team is right now. It’s less about talent and more about trust — and clearly, they’re still not sure what they have in Kyler.

Brissett’s been serviceable, but this move feels like a “play it safe” call that leaves big questions about the future. The defense battles every week but doesn't have the talent to hold the top offenses to under 20 points, and the longer this QB limbo drags on, the harder it’ll be to figure out which direction this franchise is actually heading.

25) Washington Commanders (3–6)

Things unraveled fast in D.C. The early-season struggles on both sides of the ball were tough enough, but losing Jayden Daniels sealed it. That kid brought energy and poise to a team desperately needing both, and without him, the Commanders just don’t have the juice to keep pace. The defense has been inconsistent, the secondary keeps getting gashed, and they’re back to square one. This season’s about survival and taking stock of who can help when Daniels is back healthy — and that's likely not until next year.

26) New York Giants (2–7)

Sep 21, 2025; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart (6) reacts in the second quarter against the Kansas City Chiefs at MetLife Stadium.
Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

The Giants are young and raw, but there’s a lot to like about that. Jaxson Dart’s playing with heart — he’s got that fearless streak that makes every drive feel like a coin flip — but it’s going to come with growing pains. The highs aren’t playoff-caliber yet, but you can see flashes of something that could be. This season’s about letting those young pieces take their lumps and build confidence.

With Nabers and Skattebo both on the field, expectations were already being kept in check. But now, with both of them gone for the year, they’ve plummeted. Any win from this point forward feels like a surprise.

27) Carolina Panthers (5–4)

Don’t look now, but Dave Canales actually has something cooking in Carolina. Not for this year, but progress is the main thing you want from a young head coach.

The run game’s got bite — Rico Dowdle ripped off his third 100‑yard game against a solid Green Bay front — and it’s helping the offense finally settle into an identity. They’re leaning into play‑action, living off easy throws early, and picking their moments to take deep shots later. For a team that was supposed to be an absolute train wreck, that’s progress.

Defensively, it’s not pretty, but it's the kind of gritty football that keeps you in games late. Somehow, this group that everyone assumed would be the league’s doormat has looked scrappy, organized, and even overachieving at times.

28) Miami Dolphins (2–7)

Sep 14, 2025; Miami Gardens, Florida, USA; Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa (1) walks off the field after the game against the New England Patriots at Hard Rock Stadium.
Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images

The Dolphins’ season has gone completely off the rails — easily the biggest disappointment in football right now. Some, like Peter Schrager, had them penciled in as a playoff team before the season started, and honestly, it wasn’t a crazy take — the roster looked loaded, the offense was explosive, and McDaniel’s system seemed tailor‑made for success. But what’s unfolded has been pure chaos. Between front‑office turnover, questionable trades, and a defense that suddenly can’t stop anyone, it’s been the kind of implosion that makes you wonder what exactly went wrong inside the building.

The strangest part is how fast it fell apart. They didn’t just come up short — they completely face‑planted. The timing is gone and you can tell the confidence has slipped away. Tua looks unsure of himself, the defense has gone from aggressive to undisciplined, and the whole operation feels tense. Now, instead of talking about playoff seeding, we’re asking whether Mike McDaniel’s still the right guy for this team and if they even have the right quarterback for the future. Nobody saw it getting this ugly, this fast, and yet here we are — watching one of the most talented rosters in the league unravel right in front of us.

29) New York Jets (1–7)

The Jets just had a full-on fire sale, moving multiple defensive stars and making it clear they’re thinking more about the future rather than the next few weeks. Having them this high might even be too generous given how thin the roster suddenly looks, but they’ve still played tough, close games — and that means something. Justin Fields finally flashed signs of life before the bye, giving fans a glimpse of what the offense could be if they ever find consistency. The identity’s there: run the ball, move the pocket, and take shots when the defense creeps up.

Still, it’s wild to see a defensive-minded head coach get his two best defensive players shipped off midseason.

30) Las Vegas Raiders (2–6)

Feb 25, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Las Vegas Raiders coach Pete Carroll on radio row during the NFL Scouting Combine at the Indiana Convention Center.
Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

This team’s been through a ton of change, and it shows. From the coaching staff to the personnel, nothing’s been stable long enough to find a rhythm. That’s not an excuse — it’s just reality. Geno Smith has looked rough, pressing far too often and forcing throws that just aren’t there. The running game hasn’t helped much either, with Jeanty taking a few games to adjust to the speed at this level, and it’s leaving them constantly behind the sticks.

31) Tennessee Titans (1–8)

The Titans are in that tough spot where you can see what they’re trying to build, but it’s just not ready yet. Cam Ward’s taking a beating behind an inconsistent line, and you can tell it’s starting to wear on him. The flashes are there — the arm talent, the mobility, the willingness to stand in — but you can’t fairly evaluate a young quarterback when the supporting cast isn’t holding up.

The defense is scrappy and the special teams have stolen a few moments, but it’s not sustainable. This roster needs a serious infusion of talent, starting with playmakers around Ward and a new direction at head coach.

32) New Orleans Saints (1–8)

Aug 23, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; New Orleans Saints head coach Kellen Moore questions a play call against the Denver Broncos during the first half at Caesars Superdome.
Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images

The Saints’ season feels like one long reset button. They sold off pieces at the deadline, which made sense — this team clearly isn’t ready to compete right now. Tyler Shough’s gotten some valuable reps, but he hasn't used any of them to give you signs he's your franchise guy.

At this point, the priority has to be about the long game: getting younger, finding cornerstone players, and collecting draft capital. They’ll be in the quarterback market again this offseason, and they need to hit big. For now, you just hope the young guys keep growing through the tough weeks — because there’s plenty more of those coming.

All stats courtesy of NFL Pro.

Latest Sports

Related Stories